However CNN’s reporting discovered that some Uyghur girls had been being compelled to make use of contraception and endure sterilization as a part of a deliberate try to push down beginning charges amongst minorities in Xinjiang.
In its response, the Xinjiang authorities strongly denied the claims of genocide, arguing as a substitute that the Uyghur inhabitants has been “rising repeatedly” in the course of the previous decade and that Zenz’s report was not “according to the true scenario in Xinjiang.”
In keeping with the federal government, the inhabitants of Xinjiang rose by greater than three million individuals, or nearly 14%, between 2010 and 2018, with the Uyghur inhabitants rising quicker than the area’s common price.
“The rights and pursuits of Uyghur and different ethnic minorities have been absolutely protected,” the response mentioned. “The so-called ‘genocide’ is pure nonsense.”
Start price plunges
However the authorities did not dispute the rise in sterilizations or the hole within the ratio of latest intrauterine units (IUDs) between Xinjiang and the remainder of mainland China. Whereas IUD implants have plunged in China total, falling to simply 21 per 100,000 individuals in 2018, in Xinjiang they’re turning into more and more widespread.
The Xinjiang authorities mentioned in its response that the beginning price within the area had dropped from 15.88 per 1,000 individuals in 2017 to 10.69 per 1,000 individuals in 2018. The fax mentioned that the drop was attributable to “the great implementation of the household planning coverage.”
The Xinjiang authorities attributed the sudden drop in inhabitants to Beijing’s household planning insurance policies lastly being correctly applied within the area after 2017.
“In 2018, the variety of newborns decreased by roughly 120,000 in contrast with 2017, of which about 80,000 had been due to higher implementation of household planning coverage in accordance with legislation, in line with estimates by the well being and statistics division,” the response to CNN mentioned. The federal government insisted that those that complied with the household planning insurance policies did so voluntarily.
The federal government attributed the remaining 40,000 fewer infants to elevated schooling and financial improvement, leading to fewer youngsters within the area. The Xinjiang authorities didn’t embody the 2019 beginning figures for the area.
“As part of China, Xinjiang implements household planning insurance policies in accordance with nationwide legal guidelines and rules, and has by no means formulated and applied household planning insurance policies for a single ethnic minority,” the response mentioned.
However Zenz identified that adjustments to the pure beginning price ought to happen over a number of years or perhaps a decade, not within the area of 12 to 36 months.
In reference to the federal government’s claims that compliance with the household planning insurance policies had been voluntary, Zenz questioned how seemingly it was that “17 instances extra girls spontaneously wished to be sterilized.”
“Han Chinese language lecturers from Xinjiang have themselves written that the Uyghurs resist any sort of contraceptive (and particularly sterilization),” he mentioned in an announcement to CNN.
Of their fax, the Xinjiang authorities additionally attacked Zenz personally, saying that he was “intentionally fabricating lies” and accused him of being a spiritual fanatic who believed he was “led by God” to oppose China.
Zenz dismissed the Chinese language authorities’s allegations, saying they had been “resorting to non-public assaults” as a result of they could not disprove his analysis. “Way more egregious than these private assaults on me are Beijing’s smears in opposition to the Uyghur witnesses,” he mentioned in an announcement.
Assaults on girls
The Xinjiang authorities additionally zeroed in on claims made by two feminine Uyghurs quoted in CNN’s article — Zumrat Dawut and Gulbakhar Jalilova.
Dawut mentioned she had been compelled into sterilization by the native authorities in Xinjiang when she went to a authorities workplace to pay a advantageous for having one too many youngsters. Dawut additionally mentioned she had been in a detention heart in Xinjiang for about three months from March 2018.
Of their response, the federal government mentioned that Dawut had by no means been inside a voluntary “schooling and coaching heart,” the title utilized by the Chinese language authorities for the alleged detention facilities, and that she had signed a type agreeing to the process often known as tubal ligation.
Jalilova claimed she suffered humiliation and torture whereas contained in the camps and mentioned she was raped by one of many guards.
The Xinjiang authorities confirmed Jalilova’s claims that she had been detained for 15 months from Might 2017, alleging she was arrested “on suspicion of aiding terrorist actions.” In August 2018 she was launched on bail, after which she returned to Kazakhstan.
Of their assertion, the federal government denied that Jalilova had been raped or tortured, saying that each one of her “rights had been absolutely assured” and the workers who had been in her cell might show it.
When requested to answer the Chinese language authorities’s assertion, Jalilova stood by her claims and demanded the Xinjiang authorities present their proof. “Why do not they present a video? Why do not they present a photograph throughout my time in jail exhibiting that I used to be nicely fed and never overwhelmed. The cameras had been working 24 hours,” she mentioned.
“I’m a citizen of Kazakhstan, what proper did they must detain me for a yr and a half?”