5 years after being chosen first and second total, Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota have gone from the 2015 draft’s prime prospects to backups. And their respective failures with the Buccaneers and Titans, which mockingly have helped these franchises, additionally additional tie collectively their careers.
So whereas the 2013 and ’14 Heisman winners attempt to reboot elsewhere after 5 uneven seasons, their former groups, slightly than struggling the implications of lacking on quarterbacks in prime draft slots, are, at worst, fringe Tremendous Bowl contenders. In a league outlined by quarterback investments, Tampa Bay’s and Tennessee’s fast rebounds stand out.
The Titans’ commerce and subsequent extension for Ryan Tannehill and the Bucs’ Tom Brady coup have every franchise in higher form at quarterback than both has been in at the least 15 years. Tannehill piloted the Titans to their first AFC championship sport in 17 seasons. Brady booked the Bucs into 5 2020 prime-time video games and lured Rob Gronkowski to Tampa, forming the best pass-catching steady in franchise historical past.
Winston’s 30-interception season cemented the Bucs as a franchise trapped. Regardless of a 34-62 document throughout Jason Licht’s GM tenure and the franchise carrying an NFC-worst 12-season playoff drought, the Bucs discovered an all-time escape hatch in Brady.
A damaged leg on Christmas Eve 2016 sidetracked Mariota’s profession, and his subsequent sturdiness and efficiency points restricted the Titans. Their 2019 flier on Tannehill, a participant simply as injury-prone in that span, reworked them from a 2-Four workforce into the primary 9-7 wild-card squad to advance to the convention championship spherical in 10 years.
The 2015 draft included a typical draft-era-low seven quarterbacks. Due to their first-round standing, Winston and Mariota had been the one ones whose contracts contained fifth-year choices. For the reason that 2011 CBA launched this clause, they’re the one two QBs to see their choices exercised, enjoying out their contracts.
Twenty quarterbacks have been eligible for the one-year contract add-on. Six signed extensions. This consists of Tannehill, whom the Dolphins prolonged in 2015. 5 noticed their choices declined. Three passers had been launched earlier than their rookie offers expired. One signal-caller (Jaguars 2011 draftee Blaine Gabbert) was traded throughout his rookie contract. The Chiefs and Texans simply exercised choices on 2017 first-rounders Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson; the Bears handed on Mitchell Trubisky’s.
The team-friendlier rookie wage scale launched in 2011 modified the sport for QB investments. With the wage cap at $102 million in 2006, Vince Younger signed a six-year, $48M Titans deal because the No. three total decide. As 2015’s No. 2 alternative 9 years later — on a $143.2M cap — Mariota signed for 4 years and $24.2M. Price-controlled contracts have made stomaching below-average quarterback play simpler.
It did assist that neither the Bucs nor Titans had been true title contenders throughout Winston’s and Mariota’s starter stays. Different groups in higher-stakes circumstances noticed Tremendous Bowl home windows shut due to poor quarterback foresight.
The Jaguars selecting Blake Bortles third total in 2014 (and giving him an ill-advised extension 4 years later) sunk what finally turned a championship-caliber protection, resulting in its dismantling. The Broncos’ 2016 misfire on Paxton Lynch did essentially the most to derail their post-Peyton Manning reload effort. With their Trubisky-over-Mahomes (and Watson) decide getting old as poorly because the 1984 Portland Path Blazers’ Sam Bowie-over-Michael Jordan transfer, the Bears have held their top-five protection hostage. Conversely, the Bucs and Titans reside in larger NFL society as a result of Winston and Mariota left them with out long-term plans.
In a traditional offseason — and never one that includes the most effective quarterback group in free company’s 28-year historical past — the Bucs might have wanted to recommit to Winston. The Titans reworked Tannehill’s contract after buying him final 12 months, making him a 2020 free agent. His surprising season supplied the workforce an excuse to not use helpful draft capital to exchange Mariota this 12 months.
Had Tampa Bay backtracked on Winston’s guaranteed-for-injury-only possibility in 2019 and dived into final 12 months’s draft to exchange him, Brady lands elsewhere and the 2020 Buccaneers are significantly much less related. The Titans hedging their Mariota guess with Tannehill final 12 months — as an alternative of a 2019 draft funding holding them out of quarterback markets for the foreseeable future — labored out so nicely the Bears are principally copying the plan by way of their Nick Foles acquisition.
The Bucs and Titans are additionally bonded by their new blueprints’ danger. The 2 assured seasons on Tannehill’s four-year, $118 million extension place the Titans in the identical boat because the Bucs, who gave Brady a completely assured two-year, $50M deal. Brady’s capability to promote unhealthy jerseys apart, the longer term Corridor of Famer’s Whole QBR determine fell from sixth in 2018 to 17th final season. He will probably be 43 in August, has been tasked with studying a brand new system for the primary time in ages and is doing so away from the Bucs’ facility amid COVID-19. Tannehill missed 25 video games from 2016-18 due to two ACL tears and a shoulder illness. These will not be computerized bets.
Grading Winston’s and Mariota’s careers will rely upon their work in New Orleans and Las Vegas and past. These assessments will probably be measured in opposition to Tampa Bay’s and Tennessee’s succession methods.
Though the Bucs and Titans would commerce their current realities for Winston and Mariota having develop into franchise quarterbacks, their high-end stopgap plans ought to give them a say within the Tremendous Bowl LV chase.