On Sunday’s Dependable Sources, CNN host Brian Stelter continued his constantly inconsistent file on Trump White Home press briefings – bash them once they have them, and once they don’t. Stelter slammed the primary briefing by new press secretary Kayleigh McEnany, enjoying up AP reporter Jill Colvin’s query asking McEnany to pledge she would by no means lie.
Stelter didn’t ask whether or not Democrat press secretaries had been ever requested if they might lie from the rostrum, let alongside assess whether or not they did. Colvin didn’t reply to my tweet to her asking if that query’s been launched earlier than by her firm. Persistently inconsistent.
As a substitute, Stelter’s display screen learn BOGUS CLAIMS AND BLUSTER FROM THE WHITE HOUSE as he oozed “Possibly the New York Occasions put it greatest on Saturday – ‘New press aide vowed by no means to lie, that was the primary lie’.”
Stelter introduced on New York journal reporter Olivia Nuzzi and her boyfriend Ryan Lizza of Politico, sheltering of their D.C. dwelling. He instructed Nuzzi “Olivia, you confronted a whole lot of blowback in your query.” He replayed it. “If an American president loses extra People over the course of six weeks than died within the entirety of the Vietnam warfare, does he should be re-elected?”
Stelter then threw the softball “Why was that query vital to ask?”
Nuzzi claimed “I feel it’s vital to place the query to Trump and to learn the way he is considering this stuff. To his credit score, clearly he typically will assault the individual asking the query….he didn’t do this on this case.”
No one was doing a “reality verify” on this declare. How is it correct to say the president “misplaced” 67,000 People as a result of coronavirus? Would reporters assume it was truthful to ask how Governor Cuomo “misplaced” 18,000 New Yorkers? Cuomo by no means appears to get this harshly partisan assault line in his briefings.
Then Lizza rushed to his girlfriend’s protection:
RYAN LIZZA: I am at all times stunned by the social media response, particularly on the fitting. Proper now there’s this view that we as reporters who go to the White Home and go to those, particularly Trump briefings, the one factor reporters are presupposed to be doing there’s getting extra info, proper, in regards to the coronavirus response. And it leaves out this entire set of classes of questions on accountability and among the — one of many points that Olivia raised.
And there’s this form of policing proper now on the fitting that — an argument that reporters solely — you are solely there to, you realize, discover out a little bit bit extra about what state is opening, some very technical particular informational query, and the broader extra, ‘Hey, you mentioned this, now you are saying this, why did you modify your thoughts?’ or questions of accountability, that is all by some means showboating, or not actual journalism. And that’s simply incorrect, and that’s by no means been the case since I’ve been protecting the White Home.
In my reporter days, I sat a couple of seats down the again row from Lizza at a White Home press convention within the East Room a month after 9/11, so he is been there a very long time. Someway he is by no means discovered Jim Acosta and Brian Karem and so forth to be “showboating”? That is simply laughable.